This is something I touched on in my Where the Wild Things Are review, but kids films in general get a bum rap. In that, if you make a bad family film (such as The Flintstones), everyone says 'oh, it's just for kids'. But if you make a good one (anything by Henry Sellick, Hayao Myazaki, and Pixar), the conventional wisdom becomes 'it was really made for adults'. I'd argue that would-be family classics such as Babe, Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, or The Iron Giant were intended to entertain children as a primary motive. That they turned out so good, and so entertaining to older kids and adults is perhaps simply the by-product of them being high-quality films, not films secretly made for adults. Heck, I'd argue that most of the very worst kids films (think G-Force, Scooby Doo, or A Shark Tale) failed partially because they felt the need to pander to would-be adult sensibilities, with topical pop-culture references, immature 'adult humor', and narratives that would theoretically be more interesting to older kids and adults than the very young audiences allegedly being targeted.
Just my thoughts...
Scott...
ReplyDeleteBravo. I have nothing to add, as you hit the nail right on the head.
Iron Giant is so great - "speaks to all ages" is a term I would use to describe it.
ReplyDeleteIron Giant is so great - "speaks to all ages" is a term I would use to describe it.
ReplyDeleteScott...
ReplyDeleteBravo. I have nothing to add, as you hit the nail right on the head.